The story of Morrissey's near-collaboration with Bernard Butler is a fascinating one, filled with missed opportunities and intriguing what-ifs. It's a tale that highlights the complex dynamics of the music industry and the often-unpredictable paths that artists can take. Here's my take on this intriguing episode.
The Allure of Morrissey
Morrissey, a legendary figure in British indie music, had experienced a tumultuous period in the mid-90s. His solo career, which began with the chart-topping success of 'Vauxhall and I', was facing legal troubles with former Smiths drummer Mike Joyce. The press was critical of his flag-waving at Madstock and the controversial lyrics on 'Your Arsenal'. As the Britpop scene flourished, Morrissey found himself on the periphery, seeking a new musical direction.
Bernard Butler's Journey
On the other side of the spectrum, Bernard Butler was emerging as a guitar-god-in-the-making, following his departure from the iconic Britpop band Suede. He was in search of a vocalist, and his demo caught Morrissey's attention. The mutual friend, Geoff Travis, played a pivotal role in setting up the meeting.
A Pub Conversation and a Missed Opportunity
The encounter between Morrissey and Butler at the Edinboro Castle pub was intriguing. Morrissey was captivated by Butler's music, but the collaboration never materialized. Morrissey's famous letter, 'Dear Bernard, I'm sorry - I can't', became a symbol of this missed connection. Butler's subsequent interactions with Kirsty MacColl and the unexpected visit from Morrissey added layers of complexity to the narrative.
What Could Have Been
The 'what ifs' are endless. What if Morrissey had taken Butler's song to completion? Would the partnership have led to a Morrissey & Butler collaboration? Would Butler have been absorbed into Morrissey's band, or would the song have taken a different form? These questions spark curiosity and highlight the unpredictable nature of artistic collaborations.
A Missed Chapter in Music History
The story of Morrissey and Butler's near-team-up is a reminder that the music industry is full of untold stories and missed opportunities. It invites us to explore the 'what ifs' and imagine the different paths that artists could have taken. Perhaps, in an alternate reality, Morrissey & Butler would have dominated the charts, redefining the sound of British indie.
In my opinion, this tale is a testament to the power of artistic connections and the impact they can have on the music landscape. It's a fascinating glimpse into the lives of two iconic figures and the potential paths they could have taken.
